5 of the biggest creatine myths
Myth 1: The Best Creatine Is Creapure From Germany
This is the most persistent creatine myth by far.
The claim is that Creapure, a trademarked creatine monohydrate made in Germany, is inherently superior to all other creatine.
Here’s the uncomfortable fact.
Out of the literally thousands of human studies on creatine, almost all of the studies did not use Creapure.
They used generic creatine monohydrate. Why? Because Creatine is not difficult to make, in the current age, it’s a commoditized product that can be made to a high standard easily anywhere.
And yet the outcomes are the same across decades of research.
Strength improves, Power output increases, Muscle hydration increases, Cellular energy availability improves. More and more research is also showing the cognitive benefits of creatine.
So ask the obvious question.
Are these benefits suddenly invalid because the creatine wasn’t trademarked and German?
Of course not.
All the claims of how creapure is the only brand that can be trusted, are on websites of brands that sell creapure.
But on creapure’s own website, the section that starts with “Why Creapure” there is:
-
No claim of a unique molecular structure
-
No proprietary metabolic pathway
-
No stated purity threshold that only Germany can achieve
What is highlighted are certifications.
ISO. GMP. Regulatory compliance.
Those are quality control standards.
They are not unique to Germany.
They can be achieved by any manufacturer in any country that follows proper manufacturing practices.
Creatine monohydrate is a simple molecule.
If it is high purity and free from contaminants, it functions the same way in the body.
Your muscles, brain, and nervous system do not care about branding.
They respond to chemistry.
What to look for instead:
-
Creatine monohydrate
-
Third-party testing
-
Clear purity specifications
-
No unnecessary fillers
That’s it.
Myth 2: Creatine Is Only for Muscle
Creatine’s primary role is ATP regeneration.
Muscle just happens to burn through ATP fast.
But creatine is also heavily used in:
-
The brain
-
The nervous system
-
The heart
Anywhere energy demand is high, creatine plays a role.
This is why creatine has been studied for:
-
Cognitive performance
-
Mental fatigue
-
Sleep deprivation resilience
Reducing creatine to a “muscle supplement” misunderstands its biology.
What to look for instead:
-
Consistent daily dosing
-
Use beyond just workouts
-
Hydration support
Myth 3: Creatine Will Make You Gain Weight
This is a half truth.
Creatine increases intracellular water.
Inside the muscle cell. When your body holds more water, you will be heavier.
However.
This is not fat gain.
This is not bloating.
This is not water sitting under your skin.
It’s part of how creatine improves performance and recovery.
If the scale moves slightly, it’s water stored where force is produced.
What to look for instead:
-
Stable body composition over time
-
Performance markers, not scale panic
Myth 4: Creatine Gummies Are Just as Good
They’re not.
Creatine is unstable in solution over time.
Especially when exposed to heat, moisture, and acids.
Gummies require:
-
Heat during processing
-
Moisture for texture
-
Acids for flavor and shelf stability
That’s exactly the environment where creatine degrades.
On top of that, gummies usually contain:
-
Sugar or syrups
-
Lower creatine doses per serving
-
Poor dose consistency
They’re built for convenience and marketing appeal.
Not for delivering an effective, stable dose.
What to look for instead:
-
Powdered creatine monohydrate
-
Adequate dosing per serving
-
Minimal processing
The Real Bottom Line
Creatine isn’t complicated.
It works because the molecule works.
Not because of a trademark.
Not because of a gimmick format.
Purity matters.
Testing matters.
Dose matters.
Everything else is noise.
Creatine doesn’t need hype.
It needs honesty.
